British actor and filmmaker Idris Elba is under fire following his announcement to play the lead role of Okonkwo in the upcoming TV adaptation of Chinua Achebe’s iconic novel Things Fall Apart.

While the project is highly anticipated, many Nigerians have expressed concerns over Elba’s suitability for the role, arguing that a Nigerian actor would be more appropriate.

The discourse surrounding Elba’s casting follows a growing trend of Western media using non-African actors to portray African characters, often criticized for their use of inauthentic accents and cultural misrepresentation.

Examples of this include Will Smith in Concussion, Lashana Lynch in The Woman King, and Michael B. Jordan in Black Panther.

Critics have voiced their disappointment across social media, questioning why a local actor wasn’t considered for the role.

Nigerian actors like Stan Nze and Uzor Arukwe were suggested as alternatives to ensure cultural accuracy.

According to some, a non-Nigerian actor may struggle to embody the heritage and linguistic nuances of Okonkwo, a character deeply rooted in Nigerian culture.

Nollywood screenwriter Xavier Ighorodje also weighed in on the debate, stating on Twitter: “I know there’s a need to sell the product to a wider audience, but Idris Elba should not be Okonkwo in Things Fall Apart.”

“Not when at the very least Chiwetel Ejiofor could easily play the role better as an Igbo man.”

Although Chiwetel Ejiofor is also British, his Nigerian roots and ability to deliver a more authentic African accent have made him a favored candidate for the role among many critics.

Ejiofor’s connection to Nigeria, they argue, would bring greater depth to his portrayal of Okonkwo.

Nigerians have emphasized the importance of casting an indigenous actor to ensure the integrity of Achebe’s story.

Pete Edochie’s performance as Okonkwo in the 1987 adaptation remains the gold standard, and many believe that a Nigerian actor would bring similar cultural authenticity to the new series.

“Telling an indigenous story without an indigenous character screams inauthenticity and cultural commodification,” wrote one commentator.

The argument is that local actors possess an innate understanding of Nigeria’s cultural context, which can translate into more powerful and authentic performances.

The criticism of Elba’s decision has also touched on the wider impact on Nigeria’s film industry.

Supporters of local talent argue that casting Nigerian actors helps to foster growth in the industry and ensures that Nigerian stories are told by those who understand them best.

However, despite the backlash, Elba retains full creative control over the project.

While some argue that this freedom can lead to unexpected, innovative casting choices, others believe it runs the risk of diluting the authenticity of African stories.

As Elba moves forward with the production, many hope this project will pave the way for more international filmmakers to embrace and collaborate with Nigeria’s rich film industry, while staying true to its cultural roots.